Share to:

Have you ever wondered why public transportation projects, like new subway lines or bridges, seem to always end up costing more than initially planned? A comprehensive study by Bent Flyvbjerg, Mette Skamris Holm, and Søren Buhl sheds light on this pervasive issue, revealing insights that every taxpayer should be aware of.

The Hidden Costs of Progress

At the heart of the matter is a startling revelation: nearly 9 out of 10 transportation infrastructure projects surveyed suffered from cost underestimation. On average, projects ended up costing 28% more than their original estimates. This isn’t just a matter of a few miscalculations; it’s a systematic issue that spans continents and decades, impacting projects worth a collective $90 billion.

The Impact on You, the Taxpayer

Why should this concern you? Imagine your city announces a new metro line expected to cost $1 billion. If this project follows the average trend, it will actually cost $1.28 billion. That extra $280 million has to come from somewhere—typically, it’s the public coffers, filled by your taxes. This means less money for schools, parks, and other community services.

The Role of Strategic Misrepresentation

The study’s authors delve into possible explanations for this chronic underestimation. Surprisingly, they suggest that the issue isn’t just poor planning or technical challenges. Instead, it seems that strategic misrepresentation, or in plain terms, lying about costs, plays a significant role. Project promoters might understate costs to get projects approved, betting that once a project is underway, it’s hard to stop, regardless of the final bill.

A Call for Independent Oversight

Given these findings, Front Line Advisory Group recommends a paradigm shift in how project costs are estimated. Instead of relying on the optimistic projections of project promoters, they advocate for the involvement of impartial professionals. These independent experts can provide unbiased cost estimates, ensuring that city officials and the public have a clearer picture of what a project will truly entail.

Ensuring Accountability

For too long, the burden of underestimated project costs has fallen on taxpayers. It’s time for greater accountability and transparency in the planning and execution of public works projects. By involving third-party consultants, cities and counties can take a significant step towards respecting the public trust and ensuring that every tax dollar is spent wisely.

In Conclusion

The study by Flyvbjerg and his colleagues isn’t just an academic exercise; it’s a wake-up call for anyone who cares about how public funds are used. As taxpayers and citizens, it’s within our right to demand more accurate cost estimations for public infrastructure projects. After all, it’s not just about the money—it’s about trust, transparency, and the responsible stewardship of our communal resources.

At Front Line Advisory Group, we are pioneers in Capital Improvement Bond Management, leveraging unparalleled expertise and deep industry insights. Our mission extends beyond consultation – we empower our clients to realize the full potential of their investments, ensuring tax dollars are put to maximum use through astute Program Management Consulting. For more information or to commence your journey towards transformative bond management, reach out to us at info@frontlineadvisorygroup.com

Flyvbjerg, B., Skamris Holm, M., & Buhl, S. (2002). Underestimating Costs in Public Works Projects: Error or Lie? Journal of the American Planning Association, 68(3), 279-295. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/01944360208976273

 

FLAG provides program management consulting services in Central Texas for municipal and school capital improvement bonds. FLAG is revolutionizing the construction industry and transforming client expectations by obsessing over the basics of budget oversight, schedule enforcement, compliance, vendor management, and stakeholder communication.

Join our weekly newsletter and receive a free copy of our new book!

JOIN NEWSLETTER

Overcoming Optimism and the Uniqueness Trap in Infrastructure Projects
Articles

Overcoming Optimism and the Uniqueness Trap in Infrastructure Projects

Cities routinely invest in roads, libraries, water systems, drainage, and other infrastructure to improve communities. Too often, however, these capital...
Read More
Planned Unit Developments: Investing in Communities
Articles

Planned Unit Developments: Investing in Communities

Planned Unit Developments (PUDs) are popping up in cities and suburbs across the country, promising a mix of homes, shops,...
Read More
U.S. Department of Treasury. Best Practices for Financial Transparency in Public Sector Capital Projects. Retrieved from www.treasury.gov
Articles

U.S. Department of Treasury. Best Practices for Financial Transparency in Public Sector Capital Projects. Retrieved from www.treasury.gov

The Need for Standardized Accounting in Capital Improvement Bond Programs Capital improvement bond programs are the lifeblood of infrastructure development...
Read More
Building a Better Tomorrow: Insights into Galveston County’s $186 Million Bond Initiative
Articles

Building a Better Tomorrow: Insights into Galveston County’s $186 Million Bond Initiative

In February 2025, the Galveston County Commissioners Court unanimously approved a bond election totaling approximately $186 million, scheduled for May...
Read More
Future-Proofing Public Projects: Sugar Land’s Strategic Inflation Contingency in Bond Initiative
Articles

Future-Proofing Public Projects: Sugar Land’s Strategic Inflation Contingency in Bond Initiative

In November 2024, Sugar Land residents approved a comprehensive $350 million bond package aimed at enhancing public safety, infrastructure, municipal...
Read More
The Measurable Future of Construction: Data-Driven Success in the 21st Century
Articles

The Measurable Future of Construction: Data-Driven Success in the 21st Century

For decades, the construction industry has been the bedrock of economic development, shaping skylines and expanding infrastructure. Yet, while advancements...
Read More
Welcome to the 21st Century Construction Industry – If It Can’t Be Measured, It Can’t Be Managed
Articles

Welcome to the 21st Century Construction Industry – If It Can’t Be Measured, It Can’t Be Managed

The construction industry has long been synonymous with heavy equipment, hard hats, and on-site chaos. But as we stand in...
Read More
The Blueprint for Effective Program Management Controls
Articles

The Blueprint for Effective Program Management Controls

A well-structured Program Management Consultant (PMC) team focused on program controls should have the following key positions. Every position is...
Read More
“Finish Strong: Start Early” Why Early Documentation Handling is Critical
Articles

“Finish Strong: Start Early” Why Early Documentation Handling is Critical

The construction closeout phase marks the culmination of a project—a period where all remaining tasks are completed, and the project...
Read More
A Groundbreaking Vision: Inside New York’s Service-Disabled Veteran-Owned Business (SDVOB) Program
Articles

A Groundbreaking Vision: Inside New York’s Service-Disabled Veteran-Owned Business (SDVOB) Program

From the beginning, New York State’s Service-Disabled Veteran-Owned Business (SDVOB) program has been nothing short of groundbreaking. It was established...
Read More
1 2 3 22